Posts

HIGH TREASON AND THE ANGLO-BOER WAR

R v Jameson (A South Africa High Treason. Trial relating to events 1895 – 1896 High Treason is an unlawful  and intentional attempt  by a person, owing allegiance to that person's own  state, to overthrow that person's own government.  Given that High Treason is possible only  if committed by a person that owes allegiance to that person's own  state, a foreigner cannot be convicted of HighTreason in respect of another  state because such freighter does not owe allegiance towards that foreign state the government  of which that foreigner attempted to overthrow.  The Court of the aggrieved country acquitted the foreign raiders of High Treason .  The ensuing events are not the domain of South African Legal Studies but history or politics. This  is onset of the Anglo-Boer war. The aggrieved country regarded the invasion as an act of war against its  country and declared  war against the country of which the Raiders were citize...

THE MYSTERY BEHIND TRIAL OF FURTHER SOUTH AFRICAN PRESIDENT NELSON MANDELA

Granted, S v National High Command and Others was decided in 1963/1964 and not  in 1956 The reason the year 1956 is relevant is that in that year the Charges against Nelson Mandela &, Others had been QUASHED (legal term for 'thrown out’’ ) by the Court.  THIS IS  THE O.nLY REPORTED CASE ON THIS TRIAL It is not officially documented or reported as to why they were again put on trial in 196e/64. Convinced and sentenced to life. This development is not the domain of South African Legal Studies but history or politics. 

A BRIEF HISTORY OF CRIME

State vs Lehnberg

“In any event, the impression I gained from Dr. Morgan's evidence was that she relied for her finding principally on features which Dr. Shubitz also found to be present: absence of remorse, lack of guilt, defect in feeling for others and an absence of anxiety*  Dr. Pascoe also found these features to be present but in the absence of any pattern of any irresponsible behaviour was not prepared to state that they proved that Lehnberg was a psychopath. I find Dr. Pascoe's evidence clear and con­vincing and I do not think that on balance another Court would hold that the applicant has discharged the onus of proving that she is a psychopath, more particularly when it is remembered that notone of the four psychiatrists who examined Lehnberg before the trial came forward to say that she was -( 14 -)  a psychopath.» The most that can be said is that she displays some psychopathic tendencies»”

USA FIRST AMENDMENT AND SALUTING THE FLAG

AFFORDABLE CARE - COMMENT

US SUPREME COURT OBAMA-CARE JUDGMENT

LITERARY LEGAL QUOTATIONS

MILAN KUNDERA Murder simply hastens a bit what God will eventually see to on His own. God, it may be assumed, took murder into account; . . . ─ The Unbearable Lightness of Being     But, he said to himself, whether they knew or didn’t know is not the main issue; the main issue is whether a man is innocent because he didn’t know. Is a fool on the throne relieved of all responsibility merely because he is a fool?     Let us concede that a Czech public prosecutor in the early fifties who called for the death of an innocent man was deceived by the Russian secret police and the government of his own country. But now that we all know the accusations to have been absurd and the execution to have been innocent, how can that selfsame public prosecutor defend his purity of heart by beating himself on the chest and proclaiming, My conscience is clear! I didn’t know! I was a believer! Isn’t his “I didn’t know! I was a believer!” at the very root of his irreparable guil...

VALUES, VALUE JUDGMENTS AND FACTS

BAIL MANUAL FOR SOUTH AFRICAN PRCTITIONERS

Image
(Revision in Progress) [Unless otherwise stated, all statutory citations refer to the Criminal Procedure Act (51 of 1977)] GROUNDS FOR REFUSING BAIL 1)      There are 5 grounds on which bail could be refused  [s60(4)(a)-(e)] ; 2)      For the factors which  could be taken into account in for refusal, consult  s60(5)-(8A) .   In other words: When bail is opposed in terms of — s60(4)(a) — the factors laid down in  s60(5 ) may be relied on. s60(4)(b) — the factors laid down in  s60(6)  may be relied on s60(4)(c) — the factors laid down in  s60(7)  may be relied on s60(4)(d) — the factors laid down in  s60(8)  may be relied on s60(4)(e) — the factors laid down in  s60(8A)  may be relied on 3)      There isn’t a fixed number ( numerus clausus)  of grounds for refusing bai; other grounds not specified may be considered. ...

THE CONSTITUITONAL POSITION OF THE SUSPECT

Image
Satchwell J unleashed the debate in the discussion at hand in  S v Sebejan and Others  1997 (1) SACR 626 (W). The accused was under cross-examination by counsel for another accused who put it to the accused that she had made a statement to the Sergeant. The accused confirmed this. When the cross-examining counsel put this statement to  her, her own counsel contested the admissibility of the statement, arguing that, at the time of making the statement she was a suspect and that she had not, before making her statement, been warned of her right to legal representation. Counsel submitted that this failure rendered the statement constitutionally objectionable and that it should be disallowed as evidence (at 627 j -628 c ). Judge Satchwell summarised the position with regard to those categories of persons that enjoy constitutional protection as follows: s 25 of the [Interim] Constitution secures certain rights for 'detained, arrested and accused persons'. Acco...

MURDER―WHATDO YOU MEAN ? IT’S HARDLY A TRAIN SMASH!

Image
First allow me these three preliminary fictitious examples before bringing it all back home: EXAMPLE 1 Suppose a seasoned pilot, given his expertise, can execute highly complex and life-threatening mid-air manoeuvres in any which way possible. He would often, and against regulations, take passengers aboard on some of his aforementioned exploits; each and every time succeeding in executing these escapades with textbook aplomb. One day the plane crashed. Ten of his fourteen passengers died and the other four were injured seriously. Our pilot himself had also been seriously injured and spent five days in hospital, escaping death by a narrow margin.  He is charged with ten counts of murder in respect of the deceased and four of the attempt thereof in respect of the injured. The prosecution knew that proving murder with direct intent would be out of the question (perhaps understandably so). Instead they relied on murder with legal intent  (dolus eventuaslis) . What...

THE BURDEN OF PROOF IN SOUTH AFRICAN BAIL LAW

Image
Revised from my Post Graduate Diploma in Law Dissertation, UCT (1998), Supervisor: Prof Dirk Van Zyl Smit (Dean) [Unless otherwise indicated, all statutory citations relate to the Criminal Procedure Act 51 of 1977] INTRODUCTION In respect of more serious offences, the legislature placed the onus in bail proceedings squarely on the arrested (s60(11). On the other hand, the implications of the approach adopted in the case law is that, regarding less serious offences, that one should not have regard to an onus and that the proceedings  are inquisitorial with no onus on either the state or the arrested. In other words, under no circumstances is the onus on the State (whether the offences with which the arrested would be charged relate to either serious or less serious offences). This is ostensibly an anomaly in a Constitutional Democracy sporting a Bill of Rights granting the right to bail. But their again, this right is accorded the arrested only if the interests of justic...